Decision matrix
A type of tool for choosing among alternatives.
Prodability definition
A decision matrix is a tool for choosing among alternatives that places the alternatives in rows, the criteria in columns and a weight for each criterion, with a totals column on the right. The criteria and weights are set before you look at the alternatives: the table does not calculate the right choice, it makes readable what matters and how much. The total is the sum of weight times score, and the resulting ranking is argued over the columns and not over who proposed the alternative. Each time it is filled in, it leaves a record to reread, made of weights, scores, outcome and a one-sentence rationale, which remains available when the decision is reopened.
Understand the concept in depth
A guided exercise in three phases: your own definition, exploring the sources, and comparison with the parts that hold the concept together.
Decision matrixNot to be confused with
- Eisenhower matrix
The Eisenhower matrix sorts by urgency and importance activities that will be done anyway, and sets their order; the decision matrix establishes which of several alternatives will be done, and the alternatives in play are mutually exclusive.
- Cost-benefit analysis
Cost-benefit analysis converts every criterion into money and compares the alternatives on a single monetary scale; the decision matrix keeps the criteria on their original scales and makes them comparable through weights, without translating them into economic value.
- Decision tree
A decision tree follows choices in sequence, where each node depends on the outcome of the previous one; the decision matrix compares simultaneous alternatives in a single round of choice.
Other perspectives on the concept
Authoritative definitions from different angles, to compare in the “Help me understand” exercise.
The weighted matrix is the simplest member of multi-criteria analysis: the weight given to each criterion is the value trade-off, made explicit, between objectives that cannot all be satisfied at once.
Sources
- Keeney, R. L. e Raiffa, H. (1993), Decisions with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs — source
- Treccani, Matrice, voce del Vocabolario on line — source
- Treccani, Decisioni, teoria delle, voce dell'Enciclopedia on line — source
- ISTAT (2023), Censimento permanente delle imprese 2023: primi risultati — source
