Prodability
Glossary Concept

Multi-criteria analysis

A type of family of decision-making methods.

Synonyms: multi-criteria decision analysis

Prodability definition

Multi-criteria analysis is the family of methods that compare alternatives on several criteria that cannot be reduced to a single unit of measure. It includes the weighted matrix, its simplest member, the decision tree, which follows choices in sequence, and cost-benefit analysis, which reduces every criterion to money. What they have in common is declared commensurability: criteria expressed on different scales become comparable thanks to a value trade-off made explicit, instead of thanks to a preference kept implicit. Every method in the family produces a reasoned ranking, not an automatic choice: responsibility for the decision stays with the person who makes it.

Understand the concept in depth

A guided exercise in three phases: your own definition, exploring the sources, and comparison with the parts that hold the concept together.

Multi-criteria analysis

Not to be confused with

  • Decision matrix

    The decision matrix is a single method within the family, the simplest one; multi-criteria analysis is the set of methods that share comparison across multiple criteria. The family name places the method; it does not replace it.

  • Cost-benefit analysis

    Cost-benefit analysis belongs to the family but converts every criterion into money, giving up heterogeneous scales; the other multi-criteria methods keep the original units of measure and weight them.

  • Decision theory

    Decision theory studies, in general, how to choose the preferable option among several possible ones by looking at the consequences; multi-criteria analysis is the applied branch that provides comparison procedures when there is more than one criterion.

Other perspectives on the concept

Authoritative definitions from different angles, to compare in the “Help me understand” exercise.

Multi-criteria analysis deals with decisions in which there is more than one relevant objective and the objectives conflict with each other: its proper subject is preferences and value trade-offs, not the calculation that follows from them.

Sources

  • Keeney, R. L. e Raiffa, H. (1993), Decisions with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs — source
  • Treccani, Decisioni, teoria delle, voce dell'Enciclopedia on line — source

Articles that discuss it