Prodability
Glossary Concept

Weighted criterion

A type of decision criterion.

Synonyms: weighted criteria

Prodability definition

A weighted criterion is a decision criterion assigned a stated weight, which establishes its influence on the total relative to the other criteria in the same grid. The weight is written down before you know the scores and comes with a one-line rationale: it is the value trade-off made explicit between goals that cannot all be met at once. In the calculation, each alternative's score is multiplied by the criterion's weight and the products are added up. A weighted criterion counts more than the others, and says so: the weight written in the column makes explicit what stays implicit in the discussion.

Understand the concept in depth

A guided exercise in three phases: your own definition, exploring the sources, and comparison with the parts that hold the concept together.

Weighted criterion

Not to be confused with

  • Score

    The score measures how well a single alternative meets a criterion and is assigned by looking at the alternatives; the weight measures how much that criterion matters to the company and is set beforehand, regardless of the alternatives on the table.

  • Knockout criterion

    A knockout criterion removes from the grid the alternatives that do not meet it and does not contribute to the total; a weighted criterion excludes no alternative and contributes to the total in proportion to its weight.

  • Simple sum

    A simple sum treats all criteria as equivalent and ranks by the number of criteria met; weighting introduces a stated ranking among the criteria, which can overturn that ranking.

Other perspectives on the concept

Authoritative definitions from different angles, to compare in the “Help me understand” exercise.

The weight of a criterion expresses a rate of substitution between objectives: how much you are willing to give up on one dimension to gain on another. It is a statement of value, not a technical measure of the criterion.

Sources

  • Keeney, R. L. e Raiffa, H. (1993), Decisions with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs — source
  • Dawes, R. M. (1979), The robust beauty of improper linear models in decision making — source

Articles that discuss it