Decision rule
A type of governance mechanism for group discussion.
Prodability definition
A decision rule is the explicit criterion that establishes how a decision is reached in a group discussion: consensus, majority vote or consultative decision. The rule must be declared before the discussion, not after. Without a declared rule, participants interpret the nature of the discussion on their own, producing incompatible expectations and later frustration. When the rule is declared at the start, participants know what they are doing and judge the outcome on that criterion, not on expectations that differ from one person to the next.
Understand the concept in depth
A guided exercise in three phases: your own definition, exploring the sources, and comparison with the parts that hold the concept together.
Decision ruleNot to be confused with
- Decision-making process
The decision-making process describes the cognitive and organizational path that leads to a choice (gathering information, analysis, choice). The decision rule is only the formal criterion that defines who decides and how — a specific component of the broader process.
- Agenda
The agenda lists the topics under discussion; the decision rule specifies how each topic will be decided. They are complementary: you can have an agenda without an explicit decision rule (a common mistake).
Other perspectives on the concept
Authoritative definitions from different angles, to compare in the “Help me understand” exercise.
The decision rule is the statement made in the first 2 minutes of every meeting: 'today we decide by majority / today we gather perspectives and then I decide / today we look for an agreement everyone can work with.'
