5 Whys
A type of root cause analysis technique.
Prodability definition
The 5 whys are a root cause analysis technique originally attributed to Sakichi Toyoda and systematized by Taiichi Ohno at Toyota: you repeatedly ask "why?" of every answer you get, until you reach a structural cause that leads to an action different from the initial one. The technique is an analysis tool within the PDCA or A3 phases, not an alternative to the process.
Understand the concept in depth
A guided exercise in three phases: your own definition, exploring the sources, and comparison with the parts that hold the concept together.
5 WhysNot to be confused with
- Brainstorming
Brainstorming generates hypotheses about causes without testing them; the 5 whys question them in causal sequence until they reach a structural cause. The 5 whys start from a single hypothesis and dig into it; brainstorming widens the field.
- Ishikawa diagram
The fishbone collects possible causes by category, in parallel; the 5 whys dig into a single causal chain, in sequence. They are often used together: the fishbone selects the causes to investigate, the 5 whys dig into them.
- Individual reprimand
An individual reprimand holds a person to account for what they did not do and ends with a promise to pay more attention. The 5 whys change the target: "they didn't do it" is followed by the question of what prevented them from doing it, and the chain stops at a missing document, tool or step, that is, at a condition the company can change.
Other perspectives on the concept
Authoritative definitions from different angles, to compare in the “Help me understand” exercise.
The 5 whys are Toyota's method for reaching the root cause: by asking "why" five times in a row of each answer, you trace back from the visible manifestation of the problem to its structural cause — often distant and not obvious from the surface.
Sources
- Imai, M. (1986), Kaizen: The Key to Japan's Competitive Success
- Rother, M. (2010), Toyota Kata: Managing People for Improvement, Adaptability, and Superior Results
