Improvement suggestion
A type of formalized operational idea.
Prodability definition
An improvement suggestion is the idea of the person who carries out an activity to change one detail of it — a work sequence, where a material is kept — written down to be evaluated and to receive an answer by a set date. It differs from an informal suggestion, which does not commit the person who gives it, because it awaits an answer by definition: it exists when it is written with a name on it and when it is evaluated with declared criteria, even if the answer is a reasoned no. It concerns the way of working in an existing process, not a resource to buy or a new product, and stays at a size the department can implement on its own.
Understand the concept in depth
A guided exercise in three phases: your own definition, exploring the sources, and comparison with the parts that hold the concept together.
Improvement suggestionNot to be confused with
- Informal suggestion
An informal suggestion recommends what to do or not do and does not commit the person who gives it; an improvement suggestion awaits an answer by definition, because it is written with a name on it and with the date on which it will be evaluated. The suggestion box carries this limit in its very design: it collects ideas without committing anyone to answer.
- Complaint
A complaint points out that something is wrong — "the shelving is awkward" — without saying what to do differently; the suggestion contains the change it asks to have evaluated, and so it can be measured by cost, time and reversibility.
- Request
A request asks for a resource — a new drill — while the suggestion concerns a way of working within an existing process. The first is evaluated as a purchase, the second as a change of sequence.
- Business innovation
Innovation introduces a new product or service; an improvement suggestion changes one detail of an activity already under way and stays at a size the department can implement on its own.
Other perspectives on the concept
Authoritative definitions from different angles, to compare in the “Help me understand” exercise.
A proposal is the act of proposing and, in the legal sense, a complete offer that awaits only acceptance: a statement that requires an answer from the other party in order to exist, not an opinion that can be ignored.
